Log in

20 January 2010 @ 01:53 pm
Round One: challenge 6 voting  

Round 1: Challenge 6 VOTING

Please read the rules carefully!

[x] Vote for one icon of least quality and make sure you include reasons as to why.
[x] We allow only specific and CONSTRUCTIVE reasons. We DON'T allow personal reasons/opinions such as 'I don't like the colouring', but TECHNICAL reasons. In addition, suggestions are welcome too! Rudeness will NOT be tolerated.

BAD VOTE: I don't like the background texture. // I hate the cropping. // It's just ugly.
GOOD VOTE: The icon is too bright and looks oversharpened. // The textures are overpowering the image. // The text is oddly placed and the colour doesn't fit the icon.

[x] If your vote is unclear or contains personal opinions, you will be asked to change it. If you don't change it, we won't count your vote.
[x] Vote for your favourite icon. You don't have to include a reason, but it's always good to let the maker know what they're doing right.
[x] Obviously don't vote for yourself or tell others to vote for you (or not for you). Cheaters will be banned.
[x] All votes are screened. Anonymous comments are off. Votes do get unscreened once the results are up.

[x] Voting closes Sunday, January 24th 2010, 11pm (UTC)
[x] If you have any questions, don't hesitate to ask!

1. 2. 3.

## - Reason

## (reason optional)
Current Mood: lazylazy
Current Music: Sheryl Crow - On the outside
Abbey Roadwhatifmaybe on January 20th, 2010 12:57 pm (UTC)
03 - The text doesn't suit the icon(the font) and the texture also doesn't fit the image.

01 - Really nice colours and a good crop.
Bellabella_farfalla on January 20th, 2010 06:32 pm (UTC)
#1 - The picture quality is quite grainy.

(I know it's a bad reason, but with only 3 icons, one of which is mine and therefore can't be included, whichever one isn't my favourite has to be the one I vote for for least quality, even if the icon is good!)

#2 - Fantastic colouring and brilliant use of textures for the background. I'm so impressed with what this icon maker has done with the original image.
liten: catherine - show me how it endsliten_sam on January 20th, 2010 08:35 pm (UTC)

#3 - too much of a disconnect between the background and Catherine's image

#2 - well balanced coloring and use of white space to frame the image
Chloë: TV: 24: Jack Bauerhp_chloe on January 24th, 2010 09:42 pm (UTC)
3 - The colour of the background seems a little mismatched with the image in the foreground.

2 - The colouring and effect at the edges works really well.